The New York Times-20080129-Who-s Black and Female And How Do They Vote-

Return to: The_New_York_Times-20080129

Who's Black and Female And How Do They Vote?

Full Text (1069  words)

In the Democratic presidential primary next Tuesday, Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton appears to have an advantage in New York City: Among enrolled Democrats, women outnumber men by about half a million, or 50 percent.

But New York's political calculus can be more complicated than that. Some of the biggest gender gaps in enrollment are in Congressional districts with largely black populations.

It's not just gender, said Lee M. Miringoff, director of the Marist College Institute for Public Opinion. Young women as well as black women will be voting for Barack Obama, he said.

In New York, though, black women generally account for a smaller share of the Democratic primary electorate than they did Saturday in South Carolina, where they helped propel Senator Obama to a landslide victory.

And in New York, because Mr. Obama focused on fielding full delegate slates in all 29 Congressional districts -- a mission his supporters accomplished -- his campaign had less time to register young people and blacks, who have voted for him disproportionately in earlier primaries.

In marked contrast to 1984 and 1988, when Jesse Jackson's supporters enrolled some 150,000 new voters before the New York presidential primary, fewer than 30,000 have been added to the rolls in New York City since Nov. 1.

Of the 5.3 million Democrats eligible to vote in New York State next Tuesday, about 2.6 million live in the city. Of those, more than 1 million are men and 1.5 million are women, a much wider gender gap than exists elsewhere in the state.

In New York, some black women said they found the historic circumstances of this year's Democratic primary campaign to be liberating.

I'm freed from having to make my choice along gender or racial lines, said Binta Brown, a Manhattan lawyer and Clinton supporter. It allows me, and a lot of other women, to look at who these people are and what they

have to offer this country. To me, it's a no-brainer.

Joyce Johnson, the state field director of the Obama campaign, acknowledged that some black women feel pulled in both directions. Hillary is the woman in front of us who has a chance, she said, but beyond race and gender, there is something that has captured this country, and that something is Barack Obama.

A statewide WNBC/Marist Poll released last week showed Mrs. Clinton leading among all likely voters, 48 percent to 32 percent. She was ahead among all women, 51 percent to 31 percent.

Mr. Obama was leading among black likely voters, though, 67 percent to 26 percent, and among black women by a smaller but still commanding margin, 57 percent to 31 percent. And 12 percent of black women said they were still undecided, a higher proportion than among most other groups.

Sex and race are by no means unambiguous predictors of whom New Yorkers will support, although in a number of early primaries women have voted by lopsided margins for Mrs. Clinton and blacks for Mr. Obama.

A test of how black women reconcile divided loyalties came Saturday in South Carolina, where black women made up 35 percent of the voters. Mr. Obama received the support of 78 percent of black women, compared with 80 percent of black men, according to exit polls conducted by Edison/Mitofsky for the National Election Pool of television networks and The Associated Press.

Mrs. Clinton was supported by about 3 in 10 women over all, the South Carolina exit polls indicated, including 4 in 10 white women and 2 in 10 black women. In the New Hampshire primary, where the vast majority of voters are white, Mrs. Clinton won 46 percent of female voters and Mr. Obama 34.

In New York's 2004 presidential primary, according to surveys of voters leaving the polls, women constituted 57 percent of the statewide vote. Black and Hispanic women (Mrs. Clinton has been running ahead among Hispanic voters in early primaries) together made up about 19 percent. The gender gap also exists in a number of predominantly Hispanic Congressional districts.

In a Democratic primary, she definitely has an edge because she's a woman, said Jerry Skurnick, whose company, Prime New York, analyzes voting patterns.

John H. Mollenkopf, executive director of the Center for Urban Research at the City University of New York Graduate Center, said that generally, the enrollment figures should favor Mrs. Clinton, particularly in her home state.

All other things held constant, the gender differential in registration should help Senator Clinton, he said. It will be very interesting to see what African-American women voters do. My guess is that women voters will be less likely to vote for him than men, and older women less likely than younger women.

Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries of Brooklyn, who is supporting Senator Obama, said, African-American women have reason to be proud of both Senator Obama's candidacy and Senator Clinton's, and at the end of the day their decision will be based on which candidate speaks most profoundly to the issues they care most about.

Ann Lewis, a senior adviser to Mrs. Clinton, said, We would never assume that women voters vote on the basis of gender alone, but suggested that her candidate might benefit from the nation's rising concerns about the economy.

Historically, women are more vulnerable and they're the budget-keepers, and this is an issue that Hillary has been stepping out on, she said.

Minyon Moore, another Clinton senior adviser, said her candidate had a record of raising issues like health care, elderly parents, making sure your children have safe environments and saw women as parents, caretakers and sometimes as single providers for households.

You'd be torn if you were voting based on race or gender, but if you were voting on who could move this country forward, there is no contest, Miss Moore said. She added, though, that since a woman and a black candidate are leading in the polling, black women, in particular, are in an enviable position in making their choice.

We don't have to be against anybody, she said.

But Mr. Obama, who was endorsed over the weekend by Caroline Kennedy, the daughter of the former president, has been working hard to claim a special understanding of female voters. In South Carolina last week, as he courted women, black and white, Mr. Obama said: I'll be honest with you. Women are carrying a bigger load. The reason I know this? I was raised by a single mom.